Categories: VoIP News

Are Analog Cameras Cheaper Than IP Cameras?

A couple days ago I linked to an Axis study that set out to prove that the cost of IP surveillance is now less expensive than its analog counterpart.

Now there is a healthy debate over at IP Video Market Info about the validity of this study.  Check it out:

Debating Axis’s IP vs Analog Cost Comparison

Some of the major sticking points are:

  • The Axis’s study assumes that no surveillance equipment is currently being used (i.e., ‘greenfield’).  A majority of organizations buying surveillance systems already have some cameras and cabling installed and a large portion of that infrastructure can and regularly is reused.
  • For any given feature set, IP cameras always cost significantly more than analog. While a DVR costs more than PC plus VMS software, that increase in cost is less than the savings on the camera side.
  • Is IP still worth it?  Cost isn’t everything, a price comparison can still favor analog, and Megapixel IP camera resolution (a big IP advantage) was not mentioned.

The flexibility, scalability, and high quality images set IP cameras apart from analog.  Remote access of live images from anywhere in the world including viewing video surveillance on your phone puts analog in the backseat, in my opinion.

Like any other kind of technology, over time, functionality continues to increase as the price goes down.  There may be debate now over some marginal price differences but that surely will not last.

Nathan Miloszewski

Nate is VoIP Supply's former Content Marketing Manager.

View Comments

  • I agree with the truth that IP systems are still much more costly than analog. This is one reason why we are not being able to rapidly roll out full IP based surveillance in the Taj Group of Hotels. Second point, most facilities do have some surveillance systems, mostly older analog versions. These cannot be dumped. Hence a hybrid solution is the best suited. We have done this at the Taj flagship hotel in Mumbai.

  • Thanks for sharing your experience. Hybrid solutions are great for adding features and longevity to your existing systems.

Share
Published by
Nathan Miloszewski

Recent Posts

Did You Know? VoIP Products Are Leading the Charge in Green Tech with Energy Efficiency?

In our gadget-loving, planet-hugging era, businesses are on the hunt for solutions that boost productivity…

4 days ago

Watch Now: 2024 October VoIP News Update

https://youtu.be/d167qfC_qCk?si=DVchHuXW_UT5dD8l Your October VoIP News Update is here! Tune in to get all the latest…

1 week ago

How To: How to Secure Your IP Paging System

Paging Dr. Smith, Clean Up Aisle 2, Johnny Report to the Office, Lost Car Key…

2 weeks ago

Shift from NEC to Sangoma: Powerful On-Prem Solutions for Business Webinar | October 2024

https://youtu.be/G8fuKPL8fSs?si=MIOeKuJM8S09K8px The time has come to make a switch from NEC, but we understand that…

2 weeks ago

October Hardware Roundup

S33 DECT Handset: Offers exceptional voice clarity and reliable connectivity for uninterrupted conversations. With durable…

2 weeks ago

Q&A: What Role Does Encryption Play in Protecting VoIP Communication?Q&A: 

I don’t know about you but when I heard the word encryption, I would think…

2 weeks ago